MFG 5.1 Anime & Manga Forums  

Go Back   MFG 5.1 Anime & Manga Forums > Anime & Manga > Naruto Village > Versus

Versus Matchup your favorite Naruto characters, and discuss who would win the battle if they were to fight.

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 04-16-2008   #61 (permalink)
Super Moderator
 
SS2 Vegeto's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: In God's Hands
Posts: 9,092
Rep Power: 20
SS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to beholdSS2 Vegeto is a splendid one to behold
Send a message via AIM to SS2 Vegeto Send a message via MSN to SS2 Vegeto
Default Re: Orochimaru squad vs. Kisame

So, after a little time away from the forums, I mostly focussed my attention on Astner's topic, so even though this has gone a month without posts (sorry about that), I guess I'll pick up with where I left things hanging.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
Except that Sasuke stated that Orochimaru was weaker than him. And except that, Sasuke was aware of Orochimaru's capabilities, with the exception of his true form, while Orochimaru wasn't aware of Sasuke's true capabilities.
That only insinuates that Sasuke was stronger than him, not that he wasn't quite close in power (which his later statement would suggest).

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
The bluff was intended to not give Orochimaru the idea that he had surpassed him. He wanted to let Orochimaru keep thinking that he was still the little Uchiha chick, and let him keep his mind on his own superiority and ambitions, so that he wouldn't get in the way of his true intentions. And it's pretty evident that Sasuke had been planning it for a while:
  • Phase 1: Leech all knowledge and techniques necessary from Orochimaru.
  • Phase 2: Kill Orochimaru.
  • Phase 3: Create a team.
  • Phase 4: Release Suigetsu, for that purpose.
  • Phase 5: Bring Karin along, for that purpose.
  • Phase 6: Bring Juugo along, for that purpose.
  • Phase 7: Prepare themselves.
  • Phase 8: Gather all information on Itachi and his whereabouts.
  • Phase 9: Find and encounter Itachi.
  • Phase 10: Use "Hebi" to hold off any members attempting to intervene
  • Phase 11: Fight Itachi alone.
  • Phase 12: Kill Itachi.
I think ignorance is the main factor that contributes to their statements. Whether Kakashi or Orochimaru, there are not fully aware of their opponents' true capabilities. Of course they could say those things, but as the reader, we know things that they do not. This isn't like DBZ, where the characters can just sense their PLs to determine how strong they are. Kakashi found killing Orochimaru as an impossibility, solely contributed to his reputation as one of the Legendary Sannin. Whether he's actually seen him fight before, he gave in to the hype. Same goes with Jiraiya and Itachi, where Kisame thought that even the two of them may not be a match for Jiraiya, stating he is "one of the three Legendary ninjas". And that is why as the reader, it's important to not believe in the hype, but believe in what we see. And from what I've seen, I think it is possible for Orochimaru to kill Itachi. He is "One of the Legendary Sannin", much feared by reputation afterall, haha.
Even if that were true, calling it impossible for Orochimaru if it wasn't totally impossible would still be pointless lying without indication. Yet, it's nonsensical in the first place. First off, you're trying to cast doubt on a clear statement where no contradiction is necessary in favour of personal theories surrounding his motives. So, let's say Sasuke was trying to hide the fact that he was stronger than Orochimaru. It can still be impossible for him to kill Itachi? Is there a contradiction? No there is not. It is impossible for Orochimaru to kill Itachi. Sasuke is stronger than Orochimaru. It is impossible for Sasuke to kill Itachi. It is impossible for Sasuke or Orochimaru to kill Itachi. Itachi>Sasuke>Orochimaru. Claiming the statement is false because of this is quite literally, an assumption with no backing. In addition, there's no proof either that Sasuke considered Hebi as anything more than a "what-if" kind of option. All we know is that he knew of each of their locations and existences, and chose to form a team. Whether he decided right then because he felt his power was now sufficient, or had planned on this and decided beforehand is not known, however it is known that there was a time that Sasuke would have given Orochimaru his body, as he expresses that he no longer has the need. However regardless, no challenge is made to the truth of the statement, for nothing in either case suggests it's falsehood. The truth of the statement is self-evident in the first place, as Sasuke is implied to be close in power to Orochimaru for whom killing Itachi is impossible, and Sasuke fights rather evenly with a weakened Itachi (before Susano'o is pulled out) with Orochimaru's power.

If their ignorance is not implied, that assumption is baseless. In Itachi and Kisame's case, we have Kisame, who just finished warning Itachi over his use of the mangekyo sharingan a second time, reasoning that Itachi's power should've been sufficient in handling the situation, questioning why their retreat was even necessary, followed by an answer that didn't include Jiraiya at all, but rather made clear that the problem was in the near future as opposed to the present (needed a place to rest), followed by Jiraiya admitting that just distancing them took a huge effort on his part. What implies ignorance in these other situations? If it's just a guess because it doesn't seem right or something for some reason, that's really not worth anything in the long run. Those statements weren't thrown in for no purpose. If you ignore statements that stand unchallenged based on things that the author never chose to express, you can basically ignore anything in favour of your own ideas.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
Well this is kinda like the confusion over the Hokages...

Yondaime was stated to be the "greatest" Hokage.

Sandaime was stated to be the "strongest" Hokage.

But it begs the question, which one is the "best"?
To my knowledge, it wasn't stated so clearly (about Sandaime's power) in the official translations. In addition, the Official Fanbook only states him to have surpassed his predecessors. Kakashi also seems to imply the Yondaime as the strongest, in his belief that Naruto is the "only one" who can surpass him, as if it is something unheard of. However, this is besides the point. "Greatest" or "Strongest", the point is simply that Orochimaru doesn't even outmatch Itachi in his own strong points. He hasn't shown to be capable of producing anything near to the level of the Mangekyo jutsu for combative purposes.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
That is true. While Deidara was airbourne, Sasuke was in too much of a disadvantegeous situation that he couldn't do things the way he wanted to. But once the fight hit solid ground, that all changed.
However, very little of the fight was on solid ground. Sasuke could perhaps have killed Deidara in a couple of instances. Deidara could've killed him a couple of times too (at the least), if not for Sasuke coming out on top in elemental rock-paper-scissors, or the summoning scrolls. In addition, the advantage of being airborne is an advantage Deidara will have against virtually anyone who can't also fly, which Sasuke could, but had one of his wings blown off to disable this.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
Lol, alright, maybe I was joking about the surfer speed. But you do understand that him riding the wave is not his actual speed pertaining to his body, but that he's using his chakra to control the water currents, right? And you keep saying "keep up", he was on the offensive at the time, he tried to attack Gai, and Lee countered it. He can't be keeping up with Gai, if Gai wasn't even engaging him at the time. And Sharingan is needed for Chidori because of the drawback of having to run in a straight line and causes a tunnel-vision like effect for the user, but the Sharingan allows them to perceive their opponents' movements so they don't avoid it. And perhaps the clones' speed was reduced, but I still stand that their eye perception is not effected by it. If that was the case, than Itachi wouldn't have avoided Kakashi's punch out of the ground.
He was only riding the wave at the start. The water calmed after it filled in the desert basin, after which point they were just running around on it's surface. He was able to protect himself while being attacked by multiple opponents, managed to block Gai's kick with Samehada's handle (not the blade), and instantly took the offensive once his fight with Gai became one on one. The first thing he comments on once Gai opens the sixth gate is his speed (which apparently wasn't worth noting beforehand), and afterwards, Kisame basically treats it like it was no big deal since those clones only had a small portion of the original's powers. In one instance, Karin also makes note of Kisame's speed: Naruto Manga Returns
"Oh my God, there's an incredible chakra...it's coming our way, and fast!"
He could dodge Asuma's attacks casually back in volume 16 too (though he didn't see the extending chakra blade), who is tier 4.5 in speed. Kisame having top tier speed is nothing new, though it was largely brought to readers attentions over time-skip events that would suggest just how high in the fifth tier he probably is.

As for chidori, you can still maneuver, but not as well - however, your vision doesn't allow you to properly perceive your opponent's movements while moving at that unnatural speed. It's not normal for your body, it's unwieldy. If someone like Gai can avoid those problems, I think my point is evident. Here's another one, though. Look over Sasuke's exchange with Lee. He needed the sharingan to properly perceive his movements. All he could tell beforehand was that attacks were passing through his guard and hitting him, and asked himself whether they were ninjutsu or genjutsu.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mystic_Gohan View Post
I believe he was intimidated and, is the reason why he attacked him, before he could become even stronger. So, while Naruto was preoccupied staring at Orochimaru, Kabuto decided to take a chance and attack him from his blindspot... and failed.

And I'm just arguing from we've seen... Yonbi Naruto, able to send Kabuto flying using nothing but his chakra, destroying the bridge, leveling the forest and creating a crater, dismembering Orochimaru with single strikes, creating a shockwave just by waving his hands, forcing Orochimaru to use his Kawarimi no Jutsu like 4 times, even Orochimaru states that Yonbi Naruto's concentrated ball of chakra attack would be "unavoidable death" if hit by it.

And what has Kisame showed us that's even close that level...?
He could've left it to Orochimaru. However, even if that was the case, he was pretty calm around Ichibi Naruto. However, Kabuto doesn't look frightened, so it seems more like your assuming his motive was fear out of only convenience for your point. Kabuto already saw what Ichibi Naruto could do, too.

The only thing that blowing crap up and creating shock waves proves is that his power is sufficient to blow crap up and create shock waves. "He looks strong" doesn't prove anything. I could tell you a lot of characters in Naruto "look stronger" than characters they are weaker than. Also, it's expected that waving around an intense, unstable mass of ludicrous chakra and blowing things up is going to cause more of a disturbance than normal. To be honest, no one else has really done the things you've listed, have they? Are you going to insinuate Yonbi Naruto is the strongest character in the series because of this?

We haven't even seen Kisame fight full out. But, considering Shukaku's power could probably be compared to someone like Orochimaru (2nd host), the Yonbi is notably more powerful than that, and Kisame came out of a fight with the Yonbi feeling "a little tired", let alone three tails difference between it and the Ichibi, I rest my case.
__________________
SS2 Vegeto is offline  
Digg this Post!Add Post to del.icio.usBookmark Post in TechnoratiFurl this Post!
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks


Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:02 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
LinkBacks Enabled by vBSEO 3.1.0